How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie?

March 15, 2023

Even thinking of chicken pot pie makes my taste buds crave for them. Since hot chicken pie is a perfect main dish for cold weather, my family makes chicken pot pie mainly during cold seasons. But you can eat them when the sunshine is bright too. So knowing how to reheat chicken pot pie is essential for a food lover because there can be occasions where you have to deal with leftover chicken pot pie. Who doesn’t want to taste the flaky pastry crust with a creamy filling inside? Did I make you impatient? Then let’s dive into the methods of reheating chicken pot pie.

There are several methods to reheat chicken pot pie. And I am going to share my experience. You can select any way according to your preference. But I will leave what is the best method according to my knowledge.

MethodTemperatureAverage Time Taken
StoveMedium heat5-7 minutes
MicrowaveMedium heat1-2 minutes
Air fryer400 0 F8-10 minutes
Convection oven300 0 F10-15 minutes
Toaster oven350 0 F10-15 minutes

Can You Eat a Chicken Pot Pie Next Day?

Yes, of course. I know from experience that reheating chicken pot pie does not harm you if you follow the correct storage methods. Accordingly, make sure to use an air-tight container to store them. You can preserve them for up to 3-4 days. So after storing, you have several methods to reheat chicken pot pie. So why do you worry without knowing how to reheat chicken pie? You are almost there. But I should remind you that the crispiness of the chicken pot pie might not be the same after reheating. But it is still worth the taste.

Is Chicken Pot Pie OK to Reheat?

Yes, why not? Like many other leftover food, chicken pot pie is entirely ok to reheat and enjoy. That is why food reviewers have introduced several methods for you to know how to reheat chicken pot pie. Spoiler alert- Even though there are several methods, my favorite is the oven. But don’t worry. Those who haven’t got an oven at home, are left with other options. So, here we go!

Before jump in to the methods, I suggest you to read complete guide on how to reheat orange chicken.

how to reheat chicken pot pie in Stove

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in Stove?

I use the stove when I have a small chicken pot pie. I have experienced some drawbacks when I use the stove. For example, when I try reheating a big portion of chicken pot pie on the stove, they don’t reheat evenly. As a result, that crunchy texture doesn’t come at the end. But if I reheat a small portion, I don’t face that issue. So, if you have an oven at home, use it o reheat a big portion of chicken pot pie. Without further adieu, let me take you through how to reheat chicken pot pie on the stove.

  1. To reheat chicken pot pie from fridge, take it out from the refrigerator. And let it come to room temperature. As a result, you can get an even reheat.
  2. Next, take a skillet or a saucepan. And add some oil and let it heat under medium heat.
  3. Now, place the chicken pot pie in the skillet.
  4. I usually cover the lid and reheat it for 5-7 minutes. Moreover, shake it for a better and even reheating process.
  5. After, take it off the stove and let it be cool before serving.

That is all you have to do to reheat chicken pot pie on the stove.

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in Microwave?

Can you microwave a chicken pot pie? Well, when it comes to microwaves, I don’t really like this method though it is the quickest method. The reason is, guys, when you use the microwave to reheat your favorite chicken pot pie, it becomes soggy. And many food reviewers also confirm what I have experienced. So I strongly recommend you not to microwave chicken pot pie unless you are in a time crunch.

However, I know that one of you may have to go for this method once in a while. So here is how to reheat chicken pot pie in the microwave.

  1. Take a microwave-safe plate and place chicken pot pie on it.
  2. Cover the dish with a wet paper towel. This stops your pie from getting dry.
  3. Chicken pot pie microwave time is 1-2 minutes. But if you think your pie should reheat more, you can keep it for another few seconds.
  4. Now, all is set to go!
Chicken tenders are one of my favorite! This is how I used different methods to reheat chicken tenders!

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in Air Fryer?

Now we have come to the exciting ground as an air fryer is one of my favorite methods to reheat chicken pot pie. More frequently I use my commercial air fryer for this.. So, guys, this method is so good because it circulates hot air well through chicken pot pie. Besides, this method is quick. I recommend you try this method to see some incredible results.

Here is how to reheat chicken pot pie in an air fryer.

  1. Preheat the air fryer to 400 0 F.
  2. Now, place the chicken pot pie in the air fryer basket. Moreover, if you are taking it out of the fridge, cool it before reheating it.
  3. 8-10 minutes are enough for the chicken pot pie to heat through. But this time may vary depending on how large your pie portion is.
  4. Moreover, don’t forget to flip the chicken pot pie during that time.
  5. Finally, all set to serve!
How to reheat chicken pot pie in convection oven

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in Convection Oven?

This is my favorite method to reheat chicken pot pie. The result of the flaky crust it gives makes me mouthwatering. Even though the convection oven takes a bit longer to reheat your chicken pot pie, it is definitely worth the waiting.

So here is how to reheat chicken pot pie in the microwave.

  1. Preheat the oven to 300 0 F.
  2. It would be better if you cover the chicken pot pie with Aluminum foil.
  3. Bake it for 15 minutes.
  4. If you think your desired crusty and flaky texture hasn’t come yet, reheat for another 10-15 minutes.
You might think about grinding chicken bones! This is how correctly grind bones using food processors.

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie in Toaster Oven?

Here comes another perfect method. And guys reheating chicken pot pie in a toaster oven is almost similar to the convection oven method. But it is more time-consuming than the convection oven. However, I can assure you of the incredible results this method will give you.

Here is how to reheat chicken pot pie in a toaster oven.

  1. First, preheat the toaster oven to 350 0 F.
  2. Place the chicken pot pie on a baking dish. And don’t forget to cover it with aluminum foil.
  3. Next, keep the baking dish in the oven and bake for about 10-15 minutes.
  4. After all, if you want to make it more crunchy, let it be in the oven for another 5-10 minutes.
  5. Finally, your golden and crunchy chicken pot pie is ready after reheating.

How to Store Chicken Pot Pie For the Purpose of Reheating?

If you are searching for how to reheat chicken pot pie, how to store it for reheating is a must-topic to know. And you must read proper guidelines to reheat frozen chicken pot pie. Therefore, please don’t skip this part. Otherwise, you will be disappointed with the results of reheating.

Follow the below steps to store chicken pot pie for reheating purposes.

  1. Before storing them in the fridge, ensure that the chicken pot pie has come to room temperature.
  2. Second, to prevent air from entering a pie, wrap it with suitable paper.
  3. Next, place the wrapped pie in an air-tight container.
  4. Then you can keep the carefully wrapped chicken pot pie in the refrigerator. When you refrigerate, you can keep it for 3-4 days. However, if you intend to keep it in the freezer, it can last up to 4 months.
how to reheat chicken pot pie in microwave

How Do You Keep Chicken Pot Pie From Getting Soggy?

Now I am going to share some of my secrets (literally all) to keep chicken pot pie from getting soggy. So if you also don’t know how to reheat chicken pot pie properly, here is your solution.

One thing that I do is preheat the crust. This is actually to do when you cook chicken pot pie. Another tip I use while cooking chicken pot pie is that I don’t overfill the pie. That enables a better crunchy texture.

When reheating, the following tips might be helpful for you to keep the chicken pot pie from getting soggy. Most importantly, follow the said storing methods. And ensure that you keep timing properly and heat at the correct level.

I recommend to read step by step guide on how to reheat general TSO chicken before jump in to the FAQ section.


How Hot Should Reheated Chicken Pot Pie Be?

When you reheat chicken pot pie, it should heat through to the point that you can heat the filling well. Reheating the crust only isn’t enough to get the best results. The reheat chicken pot pie internal temperature is 165 0 F. Why is this so important? It is because heat destroys bacteria in the filling. Since the filling is creamy, bacteria might be there. So reheating at the correct temperature is a must.

Can You Reheat Chicken Pie Twice?

Even though you can reheat chicken pie twice, many food reviewers do not recommend it. The reason is bacteria. Therefore, it is recommended to reheat chicken pie only once.

How to Reheat Chicken Pot Pie from KFC?

Reheating KFC chicken pot pie is not rocket science. To that end, you can use the oven method. Moreover, remember to remove the KFC wrapping and wrap it with foil before reheating.

What Is The Best Way To Reheat A Chicken Pot Pie?

According to my experience, the best way to reheat chicken pot pie is the oven method. However, depending on the type of pie and the time you have, you can go for other forms too. However, when you use the oven, everything in the willing and the crust reheat evenly and adequately. If you are searching for how to reheat chicken pot pie and the best method, I recommend the oven method.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply